What Books Do you Really Need for Class?

How many of these books do you actually need?

How many of these books do you actually need?

 

By Jake Chapman 

(UTC/The Loop/ Chattanooga)  UTC students believe not every single class needs a book these days and that the huge demand for more books in some classes is becoming absolutely outrageous.

One of the things that all students can complain about, or just be irate mad about these days, is the overall price and demand on books for classes. But it’s not the prices that are mainly bothering students, its the need for the book even though most of them will not use the extra book they have to purchase because professors will put up all the information they need on Blackboard.

Students believe that books aren’t the only thing being that’s too high of a price and being used at minimum.

  • Books for general education classes
  • Access codes for online work for classes
  • Requirements by teachers to purchase these books

So the question that most UTC students are asking everybody is “Why do I need this and give the Bookstore more money for it?”
UTC Bookstore Window

Many students believe that books are quite possibly one of the biggest scams most schools have to offer.  It’s a necessity that all students need, but they have to pay a big price for all of them.

Are Books becoming less used in classrooms today?

UTC student looking for books he needs for class.

UTC student looking for books he needs for class.

Senior Communications student Jacob Cagle stated that most of the books he has bought for classes are barely used due to the use of blackboard and notes he takes it class.

“There’s been classes where I have bought a $200 book, and I literally used it once because my professor said that was the only time to use it,” Cagle said.  ”So, to answer your question, I don’t know if I would buy my books at the book store.  We don’t get that option and choose.”

Cagle wasn’t the only student who went through the same experience.  Kevin Alana, a junior HHP Pre Professional student, said that most of his class had books, but he barely opened those books during the semester because his teacher would give him the notes he needed to learn for the tests.

“I got a book this year.  I only rented it for $100 dollars still, but I could go to class easily and get the notes that I needed,” Alana stated.  ”Basically, the book I rented was just a waste of money.”

Melody Shenkman, another junior HHP Pre Professional major, is in anatomy this semester, and has opened her book a grand total of 4 times.  Shenkman says that books aren’t the only thing she hasn’t used that much this semester, but the access codes for her online classes hardly reflect what she has learned in class this semester.

“For my online physiology and anatomy, I had to purchase a online textbook and the grand total of it was $115 and I barely used the online book,” Shenkman said. “Students have already enough stress as it is to get into the classes that they need so textbooks should become less stressful for us.”

Shenkman believes that teachers should forewarn students about textbook prices and how often they really need to use the book for that class.

So what is necessary anymore for classes? Are books becoming obsolete now a days that students don’t even need them anymore? With such advances with online work and information given to you for showing up to class, books are becoming less used by everyone, including professors. So it’s best for students to know what books are actually needed for classes and how often they will use them in order to save a good amount of money.

For more information about other problems when it comes to buying books for the semester, check out Planning a Course: Choosing and Using Instructional MaterialStudents Pay for Textbooks They don’t even Use, and The Budget Savvy UTC Student and learn more about how to save money and know how to have a better semester both educationally and financially.

 


Print Friendly

UTC Students Speak Out About Online Access Codes

By: Megan Montgomery

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn (UTC/The Loop) — The times of technology are advancing and so are the prices of online websites used in the classroom. In addition to the price of textbooks, students are now asked to buy online access codes for some classes in order to do homework and other activities.

PasswordThe biggest problem facing students is the hefty price of an access code in addition to a textbook. Forty-two percent of students in a class requiring online access are asked to purchase a textbook as well, according to a survey recently conducted.

One professor at UTC says that she was unaware of the initial price of the online access code when it was first required for her students. She has seen more effective learning with the additional practice outside of the classroom and considers the online work a necessity.

Sophomore Alexis Scott says she likes online work because it shows you the correct answer right away, unlike having to wait on a test to see what you need to work on.

Freshman, Jenna Stewart uses a website to complete work for her Spanish class. She says, “The answers are really obscure and way too specific so I end up missing the questions.”

Stewart doesn’t believe the material is worth her money because she learns more from the lecture and the book.

This isn’t a problem faced only by students at UTC. University of Maine student Luke Thomas took to the internet when he and his fiance at the time were both forced to buy a $150 bundle for an English class. They attempted to share a book and access code, but the code, which could only be purchased in addition to the textbook, was essential to participation in the class discussion.

Screen shot 2014-04-14 at 1.41

UTC offers direct access to buying textbooks online through the Barnes and Noble campus bookstore

The situation presented by textbook providers is that access codes are very rarely offered separately from a textbook, forcing students to spend the extra buck. This process makes the value of textbooks near to nothing because bookstores are unwilling to buy back a book that can only be sold with an access code.

This extra investment in online access only lasts a limited amount of time. In the survey conducted, only six percent of students have been able to use an access code for longer than two semesters.

College is stressful time without extensive financial burdens. One student suggests that online access only be mandatory if it is used extensively in the classroom not just for additional exercises. Another student suggests that the purchase of students’ online access be included in the technology fee of tuition.

Online codes and website access are a fairly new concept in the classroom. One way to help prepare for the price is to make sure you are getting a good deal on the other textbooks you purchase.

One blogger took the time to analyze the prices of the average price of textbooks at leading bookstores and compare their prices as well as include tips on how to buy smart on ExtraBux.com.

Textbook average prices from store to store according to ExtraBux.com

 

For more information about buying textbooks cheaper and more efficiently, check out some other students’ research:

1. “UTC student are going broke due to textbook prices” by Taylor Ellis

2. “How Do Teachers Choose Textbooks: A Guide for UTC Students” by Rose Street

3. “Bookstore Buybacks: Things You Need To Know About The UTC Bookstore” by Arielle Henson

4. “Students pay for textbooks they don’t use” by Kami Rowe

Click Here to Take the Survey!

Print Friendly

UTC student are going broke due to textbook prices

By Taylor Ellis

CHATTANOOGA, TN (The Loop / UTC) – Over the past 30 years, college textbook prices have increased over 800 percent.

During this time, according to the Huffington Post, the growth of textbook prices outpaced the growth of home prices and doubled the rate of inflation. For the typical college student at a four year university, the cost of simply learning the material will reach somewhere in the tens-of-thousands by graduation. With education prices ever increasing, more and more college students are running out of money and time.

On average, a typical college textbook will cost somewhere in the neighborhood of $200. Multiply that number by four, the average number of classes a student takes per semester, and you’re already up to $800. This cost alone can break the bank of the typical student, but the spending is far from over. When you take into account the supplemental materials, books that may not be required but are suggested as companions, a student may be looking at $1000 in books per semester.

But where does a student’s textbook dollar go after it is spent? Many students simply do not think about this while they’re walking out of the University bookstore with empty pockets. On average, the actual book store receives a very small percentage of every dollar that is spent

textbook$

According to the National Association of College Stores, around 21 cents of every dollar goes back to the campus book store. That 21 cents helps to supply the store, pay for labor, and go towards general upkeep of the facilities. Around another penny per every dollar goes towards the shipping cost associated with the book. The remaining 77 cents goes back to the publisher.

Here’s another way at looking at where you’re textbook dollar goes:

  • 21 cents / dollar is returned to better the University
  • 1 cent / dollar is used to ship the book to the student
  • 77 cents / dollar goes back to the publisher

    A typical college student will spend close to $1000 a year on textbooks.

    A typical college student will spend close to $1000 a year on textbooks.

With what the publisher receives from each dollar, they are able to pay the book’s authors, purchase the raw materials needed for book production, and also afford the general administrative costs that are encounter each year.

As a result of the increasing price of textbooks, many students are looking for alternate ways of getting the books that they need. One such method that has grown in popularity recently is the e-textbook. Available as a digital download, the e-textbook is a much cheaper option for many college students that have tablet devices and smart phones.

In addition to the rise of e-textbooks, many other companies are looking to gain the attention of frugal college students. Companies such as Cheeg  and Skyo offer textbook rentals that are available for a fraction of the cost of purchasing a new textbook. Also, online stores like Amazon are offering students the option to purchase either an e-textbook or a print copy for much cheaper than the University bookstore.

Dhruv Rathod, a sophomore from Chattanooga, has been attending UTC for two years now. This past semester, Dhruv purchased all of his textbooks from the University bookstore and spent a little over $900. Only two of the books that Dhruv purchased were required texts for his classes.

“I feel like it’s a lot cheaper,” Dhruv said when talking about buying his books online. “In the past, I’ve always done that. I would say it’s a lot better [buying online] because you’re saving a whole lot of money.”

Where do you get your textbooks?

As textbook prices are rising, more and more students are looking at alternate ways of getting what they need. Many are deciding to stray away from the University store, opting for cheaper options online, while others are simply going without. If the trends continues, students in the near future will not know what it means to have a printed textbook.

One thing is for certain, however. If the price of books continues to increase, the backlash from the students will monumental. Money conscience students will find a way to get by, with or without the required materials.

Looking for cheaper books? Check out the links below:

Affordable College Textbook Act

Why pay for textbooks you don’t need?

Bookstore Buyback

 

 

 

Print Friendly

How Do Teachers Choose Textbooks: A Guide for UTC Students

By Rose Street

Chattanooga, TENN. (UTC/The Loop) – The issue of textbooks is a controversial one, and money is always at the forefront of the conversation. But, a question that is rarely asked is, “How do teachers choose their class’s textbooks anyway?” This will hopefully be a little insight into how.

Chemistry Teacher with Students in Class

So, the first question we need to ask is, “How do teachers get access to multiple books at a time?” According to one Brigham Young University professor, there exist textbook publishers who send several texts to teachers, and they read through all of them to determine which would be best for you, the student.

UTC professor, Michael Andrews of the Communication Department, says that he relies on “intellect and gut” when choosing textbooks for his classes. He continues on to say that there are many questions that he considers when choosing a textbook, like “Does the book communicate out the material well?” and “Does it offer enough material, like exercises and suggested tests, that I can draw off of that there is a variety?”

Based on the questions above, I have provided a bulleted list from the Brigham Young University question and answer blog “Dear Professor, Dear Student.” Below are eight questions from that blog that a professor might ask when choosing a textbook:

  1. Does the book’s content match well with the learning objectives for the course?
  2. Is the book’s presentation style consistent with how I think students would most consistently learn?
  3. Do the problems in each chapter provide good learning experiences for the students?
  4. Do students like the presentation in the textbook (layout, figures, etc.)? Is the book engaging?
  5. Is the textbook reasonably free from typographical and other errors?
  6. Is the cost reasonable?
  7. Do other professors like the textbook as well?
  8. Does the publisher use a reasonable time frame between new editions?

If this list doesn’t help, there are many checklists online that could, like the one here.

Now, teachers do rely on different criteria based on the specificity of their classes, like a foreign language class or a math class. But, there are certain criteria that many professors agree upon.stack460The article “Planning a Course: Choosing and Using Instructional Materials” discusses several advantages and disadvantages to using a textbook. The most obvious advantage is that textbooks, when used properly, can aid in learning, and just like Professor Andrews said before, they can provide materials to help the teacher teach the students.

The video below shows a professor validating the use of textbooks.

But, there are some disadvantages. The first is that books are not interactive, and the second is that textbooks are usually thick, which can overwhelm students. Another disadvantage is that textbooks rely on dated information, and do not adapt as rapidly as modern technology, like computers.

After teachers choose the textbooks and put in their orders, that is where their involvement ends. Now, it is up to each student to choose whether or not they want to buy the textbook. I know from personal experience that sometimes I cannot afford to buy textbooks from the UTC bookstore, and I am sure that many other students have this problem.

There are a few articles that may help students in deciding whether or not to use textbooks or to be financially able to buy the textbooks that you need. Check out “Students Pay for Textbooks They Don’t Use,”The Budget Savvy UTC Student,” and “Affordable College Textbook Act Seeks to Ease Students’ Financial Burden.”

What do you think? Should professors require textbooks for their classes? Give your thoughts here.

I hope this was helpful in giving some insight into what teachers go through when choosing textbooks for their students. If you want to check out more articles concerning the issue of textbooks, check out the Communication Department blog, The Loop.

 

 

 

 

Print Friendly

Bookstore Buyback: Things You Need To Know About The UTC Bookstore

By Arielle Henson

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn.(UTC/The Loop) — UTC Bookstore return policy is less than beneficial for many students on campus.

It’s no secret that bookstores are the busiest places on campuses during buyback times. Whether it is the first week of school or the last week of school, it is a place many students try to avoid during buyback times.

“ The line is always so long. Even on the last day,” said Bre Smith, Junior, Murfreesboro.“We are all still recovering from the semester and finals and still finding all our books. Another week could shorten the lines and allow students the opportunity to return more items.”

Not only are the lines long, but the frustration grows as each day passes that a student cannot return a book for full refund. Many students are not able to predict what books will be used or not when purchasing their required books for class.

“Some teachers such as humanities teachers only use the book for a week or so then move on. It would be beneficial for students that don’t have the money for a full payment of a book to return the book for the whole semester,” said Piper Phillips, Junior, Knoxville.

The following graph is a little insight on the amount of books bought by surveyed UTC students and the actual amount used by those same surveyed students. This graphic proves that of the 15 people who took the survey 100% only use a small percentage of the actual amount of books they purchase.

Screen shot 2014-04-16 at 12.55.33 PMScreen shot 2014-04-16 at 12.55.21 PM

Some students have reasonable assumptions as to why students are only allowed to return books during a week’s time. When asked why the survey respondents think there is only a one week window for full return price, one student, Shelby Glisson a sophomore from Lebanon, said, “The bookstore knows many professors do not use the books, but if they allowed more time they would lose an extensive amount of money.”

Many bookstores have begun to urge students not to purchase a book for full price, but to instead rent the book for half the original price. While the book cannot be returned for profit, in the end, the amount of money spent is substantially less.

Barnes & Noble has a list of case studies on their website to provide students with many answers to their questions as far as rentals are concerned. Some results they have produced are that a college campus, Adelphi, saved over $250,000 in an academic year due to switching to a rental process.

According to NACS OnCampus Research, the UTC bookstore is among one of 3,000 bookstores that offer a rental program for students. The rental program cuts up to 50% off of book prices for students who are not able to afford the full price of a book.

The following video describes some of the concerns students have surrounding return policies. It also answers many questions students may have about their school bookstore policies.

If you have other questions regarding the bookstore return policy visit the UTC bookstore website or visit the following links:

Also, if you would like to take the student survey to provide more information and feedback on your buyback experience, Click here.

 

Print Friendly

Affordable College Textbook Act Seeks to Ease Students’ Financial Burdens

By Andrew Carney

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. (UTC/The Loop) – UTC students rejoice upon hearing about a bill that could provide them with free textbooks.

SPARC, the Scholarly Publishing and Academic Resources Coalition, explains that the Affordable College Textbook Act (S.1704/H.R.3538) ”will reduce the cost of textbooks at U.S. colleges and universities by expanding the use of open textbooks (and other open educational resources) that everyone can use, adapt and share freely.”

This fact sheet offered by SPARC details what benefits the Affordable College Textbook Act will offer to students, teachers, and universities:

  1. Creates a grant program to support pilot programs at colleges and universities to create and
    expand the use of open textbooks with priority for those programs that will achieve the
    highest savings for students.
  2. Ensures that any open textbooks or educational materials created using program funds will be
    freely and easily accessible to the public.
  3. Requires entities who receive funds to complete a report on the effectiveness of the program
    in achieving savings for students.
  4. Improves existing requirements for publishers to make all textbooks and other educational
    materials available for sale individually rather than as a bundle.
  5. Requires the Government Accountability Office to provide an updated report on the price
    trends of college textbooks to Congress by 2017.

The Affordable College Textbook Act was introduced in the U.S. Senate in November 14 of last year by Senators Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Al Franken (D-Minn.). Senator Durbin has previously worked in his state to lower the cost of textbooks for students. In his press release, Durbin mentions, “Over three years ago, I worked to secure funding for the University of Illinois to complete an open textbook project.”

Senator Durbin’s efforts led to the release of a textbook, Sustainability: A Comprehensive Foundation, which has been used at Illinois University campuses. This textbook is part of a “Massive Open Online Course” that Durbin says has been used by at least 60,000 students and the University has been contacted by other colleges about using it.

Had you heard about the Affordable College Textbook Act before this?

The previous successes of Senator Durbin will be expanded upon by this bill, by making future textbooks like it available. Senator Franken was happy to support the bill after seeing the success of Durbin’s prior efforts. He said in the press release, “In the fight to make college more affordable and accessible for Minnesota families we can’t overlook the rising costs of textbooks,” said Franken. “I’m proud to introduce this bill with Senator Durbin because it will help provide cheaper alternatives to traditional textbooks and keep more money in students’ pockets where it belongs.”

This bill expands upon the 2008 Higher Education Opportunity Act, which sought to provide students with more information about college textbook costs. Senator Durbin’s press release explains that the law “required textbook publishers to disclose to faculty the cost of a textbooks to their students, required schools to publish textbook information in course catalogues when practicable, and required publishers to offer unbundled supplemental materials so students had choices.”  The provisions of this law took effect on July 1, 2010 and are still in effect.

Even with students receiving extra information from publishers, a 2013 GAO report released information that textbook prices are continuing to rise. Despite the Higher Education Opportunity Act requiring more information be provided to students through compliance of the publishers, it does not mandate a limit on the amount that a textbook can cost. This has translated to an increase in the already $30 billion industry and strains students further.

Credit: Jon Sall

Senators Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Al Franken (D-Minn.) introduced the Affordable College Textbook Act in October 2013

 The Affordable College Textbook Act does not intend to set limits on the price structure of textbooks released by publishers, but it does intend to provide more open source resources to students, which will create more pressure on textbook publishers to remain competitive in pricing and offer reasons to choose their textbooks over otherwise free ones. U.S. PIRG Higher Education Associate Ethan Senack praises Durbin and Franken for the bill, and said that “for students, the cost-saving potential of open textbooks is massive – around 80-100% compared to published textbooks”, which will lead to a better education for students. U.S. PIRG found that “seven of ten current college students have skipped buying a textbook because it was too expensive”, a concerning figure which this bill hopes to alleviate.

The Affordable College Textbook Act was assigned to a Congressional committee on November 19, who will consider the bill before sending it to a vote in the Senate. To follow along with the progress of the bill, visit its page on Congress.gov. Govtrack.us, a site that monitors government bills, gives more information about the bill’s progress, and offers it a grim prognosis of passing committee with a 1% pass rate. It references that “only 11% of bills made it past committee and only about 3% were enacted in 2011–2013.”

Students interested in seeing this bill progress further in Congress should express this to their local legislators and assist in raising awareness about it as it is examined by a Congressional committee. This will show Congress that mandates are important to providing students with assistance in easing their financial burdens in the face of continually rising educational costs. They can also visit http://www.congressweb.com/sparc/23 to take action.

For other coverage about the textbook industry and issues students encounter with them, visit these other links:

Print Friendly

Students pay for textbooks they don’t use

By: Kami Rowe

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn. – (UTC The Loop) For students who want to further their education, it’s going to cost an arm and a leg. The price of a college education is rising and students are starting to feel their pockets growing thinner.

On top of paying for classes, a decent meal plan, and those “additional fees”, students are faced with the extreme cost of textbooks. The price of textbooks has increased over the years, and students are finding ways to avoid them.

UTC students are spending between $200 and $400 for textbooks each semester. The average cost of textbooks in the U.S. per semester can be about $600, a pretty penny for something you’ll only use once. 

textbook$

Where does the textbook dollar go?

  1. 77.9 cents – textbook wholesale cost
  2. 11 cents – bookstore personnel
  3. 2.7 cents – bookstore income
  4. 7.4 cents – bookstore operations
  5. 1 cent – freight expense

A survey taken by college students showed that most students are opting out of purchasing textbooks from the campus bookstore and purchasing them on Amazon, Chegg, and other book retailers.

These sources have books for much cheaper and can help cut costs by 40 percent or more. Although you can get the books for a discounted price, many students find that they hardly use the textbook during the semester.

Preston Coyle, a junior from Franklin, Tenn. said, “I have bought way too many books that I’ve never even picked up.”

A survey has shown that 40 percent of students use their book only a couple times throughout the semester and that 20 percent have never used the book they purchased.

Graph 1

To avoid buying “required textbooks” that go unused, students are using websites like Facebook and Rate My Professor to compare with other students. Coyle says that he likes to ask people who have already taken the course before he buys a book.

A downside to purchasing textbooks that go unused is the loss of money. Although you can sell the textbook back, you will not get a full refund for it.

help me I'm poor

Courtney Windrow, a junior at The University of Tennessee, Knoxville, says that the cost of textbooks isn’t any better there. “I always buy the required textbooks, but it’s the worst when they’re written by that professor. I feel like they require it just to make money, even if we never use it.”

Professors make royalties from the sale of the textbooks they wrote or helped write. It’s becoming an easy way for teachers to make a quick buck at the student’s expense.

The textbook prices are something that all students will have to deal with throughout their college career, but there are ways to save money and make sure that you will actually use the book. Students can communicate on social media to compare prices to make sure they are getting the most bang for their buck.

How often do you use the textbooks for a class? Let us know and Click here to take survey

For more information about college textbook costs click here:

Print Friendly

The Budget Savvy UTC Student

By: Charnele L. Box

CHATTANOOGA, Tenn (UTC/The Loop) – Higher education can be quite expensive these days, but could books equate to the same cost? With the rising cost of tuition each school term you would think textbooks are included; but they’re not. For students at UTC tuition and fees for the 2013-2014 academic year were $7,654 for both terms and books were estimated at a whopping $1400.

Attractive Woman with Her BooksTo downsize the cost of textbooks, the UTC bookstore, which is a Barnes and Noble affiliate, have textbook rentals available for students depending on the book choice. From personal experience, I have rented about 5 to 7 books throughout my entire collegiate experience.

Most textbook companies, publishers, and authors put out new editions every year or two. This can become a burden on students because the differences from the first and second edition of the textbook are fewer words or updated laws.

On occasion, authors may take away from the previous edition. Sometimes they will remove questions if it’s a math or science course, or even add to it. Since most of my course textbooks were not available for rental, I found another way to save money.

During the search for textbooks, I found free files of textbooks or file sharing to be a money saver. Depending on the class or subject, some textbooks may be available online in PDF form for FREE! Although you have various money saving textbooks sites like amazon, ebay, and half.com; I still came out cheaper by file sharing. art23883widea

According to USNEWS.COM, there are several ways to save money on textbooks.

1. Buy used textbooks

2. Buy E-books

3. Rent

4. Apply for textbook specific scholarships

5. Research

6. Book Swap

Using the above tools will help any budget savvy student save money on extremely expensive textbooks throughout their college years.  Although there are other sources such as amazon, ebay, half.com, and chegg; you still may have a better buy by utilizing free textbooks online or file sharing.

Christina Maximos, a UTC junior, stated she saved about $80 on textbooks in a literature course she took in the fall semester. “If I did not weigh other options, I would’ve spent $300 on textbooks instead of $150″ said Maximos.

Some UTC professors can relate to the high cost of textbooks and usually make it easier on the student by not requiring a book or putting books on reserve in the library. By opting to use the textbook(s) on reserve in the library, you can save big bucks.

3028855-poster-p-1-3028855why-cant-e-books-disrupt-the-lucrative-college-textbook-businessAt the Lupton Library, you can utilize the materials in three hour intervals before you have to re-check them out again. The Lupton Library also offers interlibrary loans. Using the Interlibrary Loan program can help budget savvy students. Did I mention it’s a FREE service!

The Interlibrary Loans allow UTC students, staff, and faculty to obtain books or copies of certain items that the UTC library does not have. There are many different types of materials that can be requested via the Lupton Library site, including books, articles, and even certain chapters of a book. Although it is difficult to get a course textbook from the Interlibrary Loan program because of the short-term loans, this resource would be great for English, Education, or Literature majors or minors.

Even though it may seem that students do not get a break when it comes to purchasing textbooks, not to mention the rising cost of tuition; using the above resources and more could save you large amounts of money.

Would you consider free textbook filing?  Click here to answer.

More stories talking about this:

* Affordable College Textbook Act Seeks to Ease Students’ Financial Burdens

* Students pay for textbooks they don’t use

* Heavy Problems for Chattanooga’s Young and Old

Print Friendly

Two Children Left in Car for a Mother’s Job Interview

pnitayloruseBy: Megan Montgomery

PHOENIX (AP/The Loop) — A Phoenix woman who left her two young children in her vehicle during a job interview has pleaded not guilty at her arraignment.

Shanesha Taylor’s case has attracted attention with her tearful police mugshot and people rallying to her defense online to raise money for the 35-year-old mother. She faces two counts of child abuse.

Court documents say Scottsdale firefighters found hot air coming into the car and both children sweating profusely.

The baby was described as wearing a short-sleeve shirt over a long-sleeve shirt, as well as a blanket. The documents say Taylor arrived back at the car more than an hour after her interview time.

County Attorney Bill Montgomery says it’s too soon to determine if Taylor will receive a prison term or face losing custody of her children.

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP’s earlier story is below.

Like any busy mother, Shanesha Taylor was trying to do it all.

The 35-year-old Phoenix woman, who relies on food stamps, left her two children in her car last month during a job interview in Scottsdale.

That decision has led to Taylor being scheduled for arraignment Monday morning on two charges of child abuse.

But Taylor’s booking mugshot, where tears are streaming down both her cheeks, has also won her supporters and donations.

A New Jersey woman set up a fundraising website for Taylor which has now collected nearly $90,000.

According to court documents, a witness on March 20 reported to police that Taylor’s 2-year-old son and 6-month-old baby were unattended in the car.

Scottsdale firefighters say they found both children sweating profusely and hot air coming into the vehicle.

 

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

If you were the Phoenix mother would you have risked leaving your children unattended to interview for a job to provide for them?

Print Friendly

Phoenix Woman Pleads “Not Guilty” to Child Abuse Charges

PHOENIX (AP/UTC The Loop) — A Phoenix woman who left her two young children in her vehicle during a job interview has pleaded not guilty at her arraignment.

Shanesha Taylor’s case has attracted attention with her tearful police mugshot and people rallying to her defense online to raise money for the 35-year-old mother. She faces two counts of child abuse.

Court documents say Scottsdale firefighters found hot air coming into the car and both children sweating profusely.

The baby was described as wearing a short-sleeve shirt over a long-sleeve shirt, as well as a blanket. The documents say Taylor arrived back at the car more than an hour after her interview time.

County Attorney Bill Montgomery says it’s too soon to determine if Taylor will receive a prison term or face losing custody of her children.

Should Shanesha Taylor Be Charged With Child Abuse?

THIS IS A BREAKING NEWS UPDATE. Check back soon for further information. AP’s earlier story is below.

Like any busy mother, Shanesha Taylor was trying to do it all.

The 35-year-old Phoenix woman, who relies on food stamps, left her two children in her car last month during a job interview in Scottsdale.

That decision has led to Taylor being scheduled for arraignment Monday morning on two charges of child abuse.

But Taylor’s booking mugshot, where tears are streaming down both her cheeks, has also won her supporters and donations.

A New Jersey woman set up a fundraising website for Taylor which has now collected nearly $90,000.

According to court documents, a witness on March 20 reported to police that Taylor’s 2-year-old son and 6-month-old baby were unattended in the car.

Scottsdale firefighters say they found both children sweating profusely and hot air coming into the vehicle.

 

 

Copyright 2014 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Print Friendly